AI and Accessible Documents: Don’t Believe the Hype

Posted by: Jeff Mills on August 31, 2023

The Personal and Societal Value of Inclusive Digital Documents

In the digital era, the promise of AI appears to be limitless. From self-driving cars to predictive analytics, the technological advances powered by artificial intelligence often seem too good to be true. And in some cases, they are – especially when we talk about the creation of accessible documents. Some vendors or enthusiasts might tell you that AI can autonomously create fully accessible content. While it’s tempting to believe, it’s essential to approach such claims with caution. 

What Are Accessible Documents?

Before diving into the details, let’s understand what “accessible documents” mean. They are files designed so that people with disabilities can consume the content as efficiently and effectively as anyone else. This includes providing alternative text for images, ensuring readable font sizes and colours, structuring content logically, and much more.

Why Can’t AI Alone Ensure Accessibility?

Nuances in Human Interpretation:

AI, as advanced as it might be, struggles with the nuanced understanding that humans innately possess. For instance, providing meaningful alternative text for an image requires understanding the context and relevance of that image in the document. AI might recognise an image of a person near a tree but might not capture the sentiment or deeper message the image is meant to convey.

Lack of Contextual Understanding:

AI models interpret data based on their training. They lack the inherent human ability to perceive the broader context in which content exists. This means that while AI can identify missing tags or structural elements, it may not recognise whether the document truly offers an inclusive user experience.

Emphasis on Generalisation:

One of the main goals of AI, especially machine learning, is to generalise from the data it’s trained on. But accessibility often requires personalisation based on specific needs. What’s accessible for one person might not be for another

Over-reliance Can Lead to Mistakes

If we solely trust AI to ensure our content’s accessibility, it’s easy to become complacent. This over-reliance can lead to errors that might have been caught by a human review.

The Ideal Approach: AI and Human Collaboration

Instead of viewing AI as the sole solution, we should see it as a valuable tool in the accessibility toolkit. Here’s how the collaboration can work:

  • Automated Checks: AI can quickly identify missing tags, incorrect hierarchies, or other structural elements that might affect accessibility.
  • Human Review: After an initial AI pass, human experts can review the document, using their nuanced understanding and contextual awareness to ensure true accessibility.
  • Iterative Process: AI learns from its mistakes. By combining AI’s capabilities with human feedback, we can refine the process, making each iteration better than the last.

Conclusion

The promise of AI is immense, and there’s no doubt it will play a crucial role in the future of accessible content creation. However, blindly trusting AI to handle the entirety of this task is premature and possibly detrimental. True accessibility is achieved through a combination of technological advancement and human touch, ensuring that everyone, regardless of their abilities, can access and benefit from digital content.

Back to Top

You may also be interested in:

  • Debunking the Misconceptions of Digital Accessibility Within Organizations

    Posted in Digital Accessibility, Document Accessibility on September 1, 2023

    In today’s fast-paced, technology-driven world, digital accessibility is a term that resonates across boardrooms. However, many organizations still grapple with numerous misconceptions surrounding the topic. These misunderstandings often hinder the…

    Read PostAn illustration of an arrow hitting a bullseye. Next to it is the universal accessibility symbol.
  • A look back: 2023 W3C’s Technical Plenary and Advisory Committee meetings

    Posted in Conferences, Digital Accessibility on October 3, 2023

    Every year around September, the W3C’s Technical Plenary and Advisory Committee meetings (TPAC) take place somewhere around the globe. I’ve been lucky enough in my role as Advisory Committee representative…

    Read PostAn illustration of a geat with three people around it to show a planning committee. The universal accessibility symbol is on the right of it.
  • A Big Moment for Accessibility: Grackle PDF Launches at CSUN 2025

    Posted in News on March 27, 2025

    Reflecting on our time at CSUN, we can’t help but feel energized by the enthusiasm, curiosity, and genuine commitment to digital accessibility we encountered. It was incredible to meet so…

    Read Post